Newspaper Websites Need Some Major Redesign
February 22nd, 2012 by Brian CarlsonI’ll be the first to admit it. I’m not a designer. I came to this discovery a long time ago when I was trying to design my own business card. A lot of photographers think they’re designers. Some are but most aren’t. Anyway, just because I am not a designer doesn’t mean I don’t know good design.
The Newspaper industry has taken a huge hit in the last several years thanks to the internet. Subscriptions are down and people are getting laid off. At one point I wanted to become a newspaper photographer. Thankfully I saw the writing on the wall and realized it was a sinking ship. With the internet now dominating everyones lives newspapers have now tried to pump up their online content.
One of the biggest problems I see with their online content is how it is designed. If there is one thing we should know by now it’s that we are a visual culture (sorry writers). Just look at Pinterest, Facebook, 500px, and Tumblr. All of these are heavily visual, some exclusively visual. If you want to sell something you’ve gotta make it look good. It’s just how we roll. Newspapers have done a horrible job at this. Take a look at some of their home pages below:

Not bad. Not bad. But certainly not visually striking. As a rule of thumb I think there should be one large image above the scroll to add some pop. Heck, they do it with print papers (see the “Today’s Paper” image on the right hand side) but they don’t do it with their website? What gives? (By the way, it’s called “Above the Fold” in print).

More images than the previous site but still boring to look at. And what’s with all the blue?

To me this is pretty bad. You’ve got huge green ugly ad on the right side of the page. Red is a strong color that attracts attention and signals strength, passion, and energy (why do you think the President wears a red tie so much?) and the only instance you see it here is in ads. There seems to be some weird negative space to the sides and below the Sears and Walmart ad which brings up another question, why would you start off your site with 3 ads?

This isn’t bad. There is a prominent picture above the scroll, though it really fights with the ugly car ad to the right. I like that their logo sticks out agains the white. And again, what’s with all the blue? I know blue traditionally indicates a link but I’ve gotta think the internet has been around long enough for people to know what is clickable and what isn’t.

Personally, this is the worst of the bunch. Surprisingly it comes from one of the most reputable papers around, something I’m dumbfounded by. There are two ads right next to their logo. To me you shouldn’t have ads near your logo. You should keep that area just for your brand. Don’t water it down with ads. Make it stand out. Ever picture is practically a thumbnail. Heck, the largest “image” is a Tiffany & Co. ad. This site is just visually confusing. It’s just unsettling and not easy to take in.
If newspapers want to gain readers online they really need to redesign their websites. Notice how each one looks almost identical? Don’t they want their brand to stand out from the crowd? Also, notice how none of them integrate social media very well? Any Twitter, Facebook, or share button is small and tucked away somewhere. Not great if you are trying to gain new readers.
Thoughts? Comments? Leave them below.



















